Best Pizza in New Braunfels: Local’s Guide to Must-Try Pies
New Braunfels might make you think first of rivers and parks, but dig a little deeper and you’ll find a rich pizza restaurant scene that locals swear by.
From artisan pies baked with quality ingredients to pub pizzas that pair perfectly with a cold drink, this town offers pizza for every palate.
The pizza makers here understand something fundamental about their craft. In this list, we featured four establishments that represent the best pizza New Braunfels has to offer, each bringing something unique to the table worth experiencing.
1. Above Ground Pizza
Location: 311 FM 306, New Braunfels
Contact: (830) 310-0551
Hours: Tuesday to Saturday 11:00 AM-7:30 PM (closed Sunday & Monday)
Above Ground Pizza has quickly become a favorite among locals who care about quality dough and interesting pies. It’s a casual, friendly spot where you can grab a flavorful slice or a whole pie without fuss.
Part of the buzz around this place comes from diners noticing that the dough seems lighter and fresher than many other local options, with some believing unbleached flour is part of what makes the crust so pleasant.
The environment feels welcoming, and it’s a perfect place to share a pie with family or friends while exploring other New Braunfels eats.
Best Sellers and Must Try Items
Above Ground’s pizza offerings are creative and well-priced, especially their 7″ pies, perfect for a personal meal or to mix and match.
Starting with the classic, their Good Old Fashioned Cheese Pizza is priced at $9 and lets you add your own toppings if you want more customization.
For a more loaded option, try the Supreme Pizza (starting at $12) lets you choose two meats and three vegetables for a loaded, satisfying slice.
They also have the Codie’s Primal Pizza ($12) that lives up to its name with homemade turkey and beef meatballs, hot Italian sausage, sliced ham, pepperoni, roasted green chile, and a five-cheese blend.
For veggie fans, the Veggie Lovers Pizza ($11) stacks mushrooms, artichoke hearts, spinach, pickled red onions, sun-dried tomatoes, Kalamata olives, fresh basil, and the signature five-cheese mix for a bright, flavorful pie.
Raves About This Pizza Place
Locals on Reddit consistently praise Above Ground for its high quality, especially calling out the mushroom pies as “epic” and noting that this spot often ranks at the top when people discuss pizza in New Braunfels.
Enthusiasts appreciate not just the taste but the ingredient quality, with several comments highlighting the fresh dough and thoughtful toppings. While some reviews online mention service inconsistencies, the food itself is widely enjoyed for its flavor and value.
2. Bootleggers Pizza Parlor
Location: 197 S Seguin Ave, New Braunfels
Contact: (830) 327-1199 Chamber of Commerce
Hours: Sunday to Thursday 11:30 AM-9:00 PM | Friday and Saturday 11:30 AM–10:00 PM
Bootleggers Pizza Parlor brings a classic pizza parlor vibe to downtown New Braunfels with a menu that leans into hearty, satisfying pies and an atmosphere locals describe as lively and fun.
It’s a casual spot perfect for lunch or dinner, with pizza by the slice available if you’re not ready for a full pie. The red sauce here has a bit of a cult following, and the menu’s variety keeps everyone in your group happy.
Best Sellers and Must Try Items
Bootleggers serves both by-the-slice options and full pie sizes. You can grab slices like the Stock Car ($5 for Stock Car, $6 pepperoni, $6.50 Slice of the Day) if you just want a quick bite.
Full pizzas include The Stock Car (12″ $13 / 15″ $16) with classic red sauce and cheese; the Margherita (12″ $16 / 15″ $19) with house-made mozzarella and basil.
If you’re a meat lover, then be sure to check out the Blind Pig (12″ $17.50 / 15″ $21) with Canadian bacon, roasted pineapple, and red onions.
For pizza lovers who have more adventurous palates, check out the Balsamic Chicken Blue Cheese (12″ $18.50 / 15″ $22) with white sauce, roasted chicken, roasted tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese crumbles, and balsamic reduction.
Raves About This Pizza Place
Bootleggers consistently earns high marks for its pizza and overall vibe, sitting around a 4.6-star rating on review platforms.
Many local reviewers call it one of the best pizza joints in New Braunfels, particularly emphasizing the well-made crust and flavorful toppings.
On Reddit, it’s often mentioned alongside Above Ground as one of the town’s top pizza experiences.
3. Calahan’s Pub and Pizza
Location: 194 W San Antonio St, New Braunfels
Contact: (830) 609-9782
Hours: Monday 11:00 AM–12:00 AM | Tuesday and Wednesday 4:00 PM–12:00 AM | & Thursday and Friday 11:00 AM–12:00 AM | Saturday 11:00 AM–1:00 AM | Sunday 11:00 AM–12:00 AM
Calahan’s Pub and Pizza is a unique piece of the New Braunfels pizza scene, an Irish pub that somehow serves some of the most talked-about pizza in town.
Locals admit they were initially skeptical (“It’s an Irish pub — why the hell does it serve pizza?”), but the quality of the pies has won over many regulars.
Pair your slice with a beer or cocktail, settle into the upbeat pub environment, and enjoy a pizza experience that’s become a true local favorite.
Best Sellers and Must Try Items
Calahan’s serves pizzas in multiple sizes, from 10″ ($12.50) up to 20″ ($34), making it great for both solo meals and group gatherings.
Signature pies include the Garden Delight, a vegetarian pizza loaded with mushrooms, onion, green peppers, roasted red peppers, black olives, and tomato.
Its name doesn’t sound so appetizing, but patrons swear by the Kitchen Sink, a hearty combo of pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, and black olives.
The Comal, a South Pacific-inspired pizza with pineapple, Canadian bacon, onion, and jalapeños; and
Another New Braunfels-inspired pie is The Guadalupe, a classic American pie with sauce, garlic, mozzarella, double pepperoni, and jalapeños.
Calahan’s also offers an extensive create-your-own option if you want something custom.
Raves About This Pizza Place
On community platforms, Calahan’s pizza receives a surprising amount of enthusiasm. Reddit commenters frequently note that despite being a pub, the pizzas are “very good” and stand up alongside other top local spots.
Many locals also say they end up craving Calahan’s pies again and again, enjoying both the unique topping combinations and the lively pub atmosphere.
4. Mattenga’s Pizzeria
Location: 2180 TX-46 Ste 107, New Braunfels
Contact: (830) 214-0652
Hours: Sunday to Thursday 11:00 AM–9:00 PM | Friday to Saturday 11:00 AM–10:00 PM
Mattenga’s Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite known for crust that strikes a perfect balance of thin and crispy with robust, flavorful toppings.
Locals often say this is where they go when they want pizza with real character, especially if you’re a fan of house-made sausage or unique, bold flavors.
Best Sellers and Must Try Items
Mattenga’s menu leans into bold combinations that you won’t find everywhere. The 10″ Cauliflower Crust (Gluten Free) ($12) is a great option for those seeking a lighter pie without sacrificing flavor.
The 10″ Honey Bexar Pizza ($12.99) blends crispy cup n’ char pepperoni with jalapeño peppers and a drizzle of sweet hot honey.
Texans also love their 10″ Texas Brisket Pizza ($12.99) uses a molasses-rich Kansas City-style BBQ sauce, premium mozzarella, and tender hickory-smoked brisket marinated in Texas lager. Truly a hearty, Texas-style pie.
Raves About This Pizza Place
Local reviewers consistently praise Mattenga’s for its fresh dough, flavorful toppings, and friendly staff.
Many commenters on community pages say it’s among their top pizza choices in town, with the house-made sausage and unique pies earning particular acclaim.
Reviewers often recommend Mattenga’s as one of the best pizzas they’ve found locally, noting that it stands up well to other well-loved New Braunfels pizza spots.
Grab A Slice Today!
Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice, a creative pie loaded with toppings, a pub-style pizza with a twist, or a Detroit-style deep dish with craft beer on the side, New Braunfels offers a diverse pizza scene worth exploring.
Each of these four establishments brings something distinct to New Braunfels’ pizza scene, making the “best” designation ultimately dependent on what you’re seeking in that particular moment.
From the mushroom lovers at Above Ground to the brewery vibes at Guadalupe Brewing, these local favorites deliver big flavor, welcoming atmospheres, and plenty of reasons to make pizza a destination in this charming Texas town. Dive in, try a few, and find your own favorite slice.
